I was recommended One Day by a friend who told me “it’s a chick lit with a twist” which is true but this is a story that deserves a bit more consideration than your average romantic novel (and be ready because it’s a pretty big twist that will hit you like a bullet).
I cannot say that this novel it’s an instant classic (it’s written on the cover), there are many stereotypes and situations that I’ve seen before but it worked for me and I found myself absorbed in the story of Dexter and Emma.
15th July 1988. Emma and Dexter meet on the night of their graduation and almost sleep together, we might say that nothing really happens and yet everything happens because Em and Dex experience one of those it-happens-once-in-a-lifetime connection and don’t let go of each other, they become friends.
“This is me.’” He handed her the precious scrap of paper. ‘Call me or I’ll call you, but one of us will call, yes? What I mean is it’s not a competition. You don’t lose if you phone first”
Each chapter covers the same day, 15th July, from 1988 until 2007, by the end of the story Em and Dex become friends of yours, I feel like if I have known them for twenty years.
Nicholls pays homage to Fitzgerald (Dexter’s character) without achieving quite the same beautiful and damned quality as Dex is more obnoxious than charming but he does have a good side and I enjoyed his character.
Dex is a very handsome lazy young man who turns into an arrogant ambitious tv presenter and slowly falls into alcoholism and drugs, self-absorbed and sex-addicted he reaches that point in which not even his natural charm and good humor can make up for his awful behavior.
Em starts as a self-deprecating, artsy, smart girl who is wasting her talent away until she starts teaching and writing finally conquering the gift of confidence. Emma has a crush on Dexter but she won’t act on it (she has a self-esteem, she wants everything or nothing).
WEDNESDAY, 15 JULY 1992 (The Dodecanese Islands, Greece)
‘I take it that’s a no then,’ he said eventually, pinching the sea-water from his nose.
‘I think so. I think our moment passed some time ago.’
‘Oh. Really. Are you sure? Because I think we’d feel much better if we got it out of the way.’
‘Got it out of the way?’
‘I just think we’d feel closer. As friends.’
‘You’re worried that not sleeping together could spoil our friendship?’
‘I’m not expressing myself very well—’
‘Dexter, I understand you perfectly, that’s the problem—’
‘If you’re scared of Ingrid—’
‘I’m not scared of her, I’m just not going to do it so that we can say that we’ve done it. And I’m not going to do it if the first thing you say afterwards is “please don’t tell anyone” or “let’s forget it ever happened”.If you have to keep something secret it’s because you shouldn’t be doing it in the first place!’
Dex vs Em:
* doesn’t care for politics vs a radical activist
* not a very brilliant student vs honors
* extremely good looking vs pretty girl (she is a redhead) with spectacles
* wealthy family vs working class
* an ass vs a girl who cares
I only like Dex when he is around Em, I love the dynamic of their friendship and I became really fond of this pair.
What I liked about this book:
* the witty bantering, dialogues, conversation
* Emma, she is precious. I adored her sense of humor, her clever observations, her fear of skinny-dipping
* quotes (some of them are truly brilliant, ‘They spoke very little of their mutual feelings: pretty phrases and warm attentions being probably unnecessary between such tried friend.’ – Thomas Hardy, Far from the Madding Crowd)
What I didn’t like about this book is how Nicholls focuses exclusively on characters and dialogues but wastes an opportunity when it comes to creating a strong background social contest, this is a story that covers twenty years and yet I didn’t realize time was passing, there are no references to what happens out there around Em and Dex.
To progress further I should probably give away a big spoiler but it wouldn’t be fair to do so, I will just say that the ending left me with a smile on my face and a tight not in my stomach. A bittersweet taste that really got me thinking about life, love, bad-timing.
This novel would make a brilliant movie and apparently Anne Hathaway and Jim Sturgess are being recruited those days, I really don’t see how Hathaway can play Emma, she is far too pretty and she is not a redhead.
If I only had one song for this book:
Unfinished sympathy by Massive Attack
I know that I’ve been mad in love before
And how it could be with you
Really hurt me baby, really cut me baby
How can you have a day without a night
You’re the book that I have opened
And now I’ve got to know much more
The curiousness of your potential kiss
Has got my mind and body aching
Really hurt me baby, really cut me baby
How can you have a day without a night
You’re the book that I have opened
And now I’ve got to know much more
Like a soul without a mind
In a body without a heart
I’m missing every part
I hope you’ll put it in your TBR list for the summer (let me know what you think).
Other reviews:
Lit Snit
Write Meg
My grade: 4/5
Em